Written by Sarah Miller
You’ve got a giant bowl of peanut butter cup halloween candy sitting on the kitchen counter, and maybe you’re like me, thinking, What on earth am I gonna do with all these bite-sized chocolates? Maybe the trick-or-treaters never quite cleaned you out, or your kids came home with a haul that’s, I’ll just say it, kind of ridiculous. I mean, it’s hard to resist “just one more…” but the pile? Still there. If you want more than just snacking, trust me, you’ve got options. Sometimes I’ll even chop a couple up and sprinkle them on my vanilla cupcakes or, when I’m feeling a little extra, mash a few into my morning batch of buttermilk donuts. Yes, really. 
Product Details
So what exactly are these peanut butter cup halloween candy treats? I’m talking about those little REESE’S Halloween Milk Chocolate Miniatures Peanut Butter Cups. You know, the classic combo: creamy peanut butter wrapped in rich milk chocolate. Each one is wrapped up in shiny orange or black foil for the season (which I think kind of makes them disappear in the pile until you start digging, by the way).
They’re just the right size for a quick bite. Perfect for lunchboxes, Halloween bowls, snack trays… Okay, or just stuffing in your bag “for later” (which for me means about five minutes). Unlike the regular big cups, these little guys are so poppable. They’re good for sharing—or for sneaking. Up to you.
A pack usually comes in a decently sized bag, so you truly won’t run out. I use them all season and, weirdly, I think they taste even better after sitting around for a week. Just me?
Nutrition Information
Let’s get real. You’re probably not thinking about nutrition with peanut butter cup halloween candy, but somebody’s gonna ask, so here it is. Each miniature has about 44 calories and 2 grams of fat. Honestly, you probably burn more just unwrapping the foil if you eat them at my speed.
Do these count as real food? Not exactly. But hey, there’s a little bit of real peanut butter in there and, surprisingly, not a ton of sodium (about 30 mg per cup). Sugar, yeah, there’s some—about 5 grams in one. That’s less than some cereal! So, you know, moderation is your friend.
Bonus: They’re peanut-based, so watch out if you’ve got allergies in the family. And nope, probably not gluten-free, so if you need something safer, check out these gluten-free cupcakes for your next party. 
Halloween Party Ideas & Desserts
This is where things get extra fun. Peanut butter cup halloween candy is practically begging to be used in all sorts of Halloween party antics. Here’s what I do (and shamelessly brag about):
I chop up a bunch and stir them into brownie batter before baking. Instant deluxe brownies, with gooey peanut butter pockets. Or, toss them on a big tray of vanilla cupcakes before the frosting sets. Kids lose it over that. At my last party, I made little monster faces with the cups and candy eyes—total hit, total mess.
For something easy, sprinkle chopped cups on store-bought ice cream. Just trust me, this turns plain vanilla into a five-star restaurant dessert faster than you can say, “Save me another one!” If you want a fancier vibe, melt two or three cups and drizzle onto popcorn, then scatter some Halloween-colored sprinkles. People will ask for your “recipe.” (You can pretend you spent hours.)
And those pumpkin-themed candy jars? They look a hundred times cuter filled with peanut butter cups. Add in a few extras like candy corn, and you’re holiday-ready.
| Item | Calories | Fat (g) | Sugar (g) | Sodium (mg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| REESE’S Peanut Butter Cup (Mini) | 44 | 2 | 5 | 30 |
| REESE’S Peanut Butter Cup (Big) | 105 | 6 | 10 | 60 |
| REESE’S Sticks | 130 | 7 | 13 | 70 |
| REESE’S White Chocolate | 150 | 8 | 14 | 50 |
Related Products
Peanut butter cup halloween candy is just one part of my annual “what’s leftover after trick-or-treating” collection. There are a few other stars you should know about if you’re building a candy buffet or working up a mix for party bags.
The classic milk chocolate bars always show up. If you want to change things up, try adding pistachio butter for a little salty-sweet mix, or use mini bars alongside the peanut butter cups in a candy bark. Then you’ve got your fruity stuff (gummy worms, I’m looking at you), but nothing beats the creamy chocolate-peanut combo.
The beauty? You can mix and match all these in desserts, or just sort ’em out for personal “research.” Basically, peanut butter cup halloween candy plays well with others, which means your leftover stash can turn into a creative masterpiece if you get a little wild.
Usage Tips
I’ll let you in on a few of my peanut butter cup halloween candy hacks:
- Chop and sprinkle over pancakes for a special holiday breakfast
- Freeze a few and blend them into homemade milkshakes or smoothies
- Stuff them into warm cornbread muffins (seriously, don’t knock it till you try)
- Toss into a big bowl of popcorn with a drizzle of caramel for movie night
The last tip? Hide a handful in the freezer. They taste better cold and nobody looks for Halloween candy in December. True story.
Common Questions
Q: Can I bake these peanut butter cup halloween candy treats into cookies?
A: Oh yes, and you probably should. Drop one in the center before baking or chop and stir into the dough.
Q: Are these safe for folks with peanut allergies?
A: Nope, sorry! They’re made with real peanuts, so you’ll need to skip if allergies are a concern.
Q: Any tips to keep them from melting at a party?
A: Try putting them out just before serving and keeping a backup stash in the fridge. Melted chocolate fingers are no fun.
Q: Can I use these in no-bake desserts?
A: Absolutely. Sprinkle them on trifles, ice cream, or use in quick parfaits.
Q: What’s the best way to store leftover candy after Halloween?
A: Zip-top bag, cool cupboard, or pop them in the freezer. Out of sight… mostly out of mind, right?
Your Next Halloween Hit Treats
There you go! I hope you’ve found a few new ways to jazz up your peanut butter cup halloween candy stash and avoid that “what do I do now?” sugar dilemma. Honestly, these little chocolatey, peanut-rich devils can go way beyond the candy bowl. For specific product info or to restock if you “accidentally” eat them all, check the official REESE’S Halloween Milk Chocolate Miniatures Peanut Butter Cups page. And if you get creative, share your wild combos or snack hacks—you never know whose party you might inspire. For more tasty tricks, this list of creative Halloween snacks really pushes the limit, and these easy DIY cupcake ideas always add a little extra magic around spooky season!
Peanut Butter Cup Halloween Candy Treats
Ingredients
For the Halloween Treats
- 1 bag REESE’S Halloween Milk Chocolate Miniatures Peanut Butter Cups Use chopped or whole for various recipes
- 1 cup Brownie batter Add chopped cups to enhance flavor
- 12 cupcakes Vanilla cupcakes Toss chopped cups on top before frosting
- 1 qt Store-bought vanilla ice cream Chop cups and sprinkle on top
- 2-3 REESE’S cups Melt and drizzle over popcorn
- 1 bag Candy corn Optional for decoration
Instructions
Preparation
- Chop REESE’S cups into smaller pieces for easy incorporation.
- Prepare brownie batter according to package instructions. Stir in chopped peanut butter cups before baking.
- For cupcakes, place chopped cups on top before frosting.
- Sprinkle chopped peanut butter cups over ice cream just before serving.
- Melt 2 or 3 cups in the microwave and drizzle over popcorn, followed by Halloween-colored sprinkles.
Serving Suggestions
- Fill pumpkin-themed jars with REESE’S cups and candy corn for festive decoration.
- Store leftover candy in a zip-top bag to keep it fresh.